Currently I see a lot of ideas being closed as "good idea but not YET on the roadmap". However when that's done, there's no way to add any comments. I think this is a shame, as especially these ideas can still lead to discussion and there should also still be room for it as they're not planned yet.
I would suggest to either allow comments on closed ideas, to introduce a new status to the idea forum, or too simply provide an answer from Mendix (good idea but not in the near future) without closing the idea.
you’re right.
same post as: https://forum.mendix.com/link/ideas/1255
Another example: here Mendix ask a question but also closes the idea, does not work...